work on this idea more it's good

A much simpler idea is a weighted lottery distribution system. Leaders define the "worth" of activities members take part in. And when distributing packs then can click to randomize distribution. Those with more points will high a higher chance to gain a pack, but overall its still luck, so its fair.

Ex: Leading convoy 1 pt.
Assist in convoy .5 pt
Leading TI 1 pt.
Assist in TI .5 pt.
Lead Group Instance 1pt.
Assist in Group Instance .5 pt
Attend 1 round of GNW 2 pts.
Cheer 1 round of GNW 1 pts.
Gold donation 100k per pt. (Max 5 pts per week, prevents top players in ninetails from buying packs so to speak and everyone can spare 500k coins every week, and 500k coins is easily obtainable by a active player)
Leader Commodation +1 pt. (If you see a player go above and beyond for others, helping make teams, etc etc, Max 2 pts per group member)

I was debating on whether or not people have to have attended GNW at least 1 round to be eligible

It doesnt matter how you do it to be honest ther are always ppl who wont acceptd it for some it takes too long to get a pack and some always complain. Just let the Leader distribute based on his feelings about the member obv he shouldnt give the same ppl over and over packs but as far as i can tell there is a huge % of the ppl in GNW who dont rly do as much as other and i rather would focus on the core members who always come to gnw and rly improve everytime. You dont need to be the best dps or smt like this but a leader can tell if a person wants to improve and learn more. Idk how many particpate in your groups but on s1 our group its full fields and we are 95% f2p player but our ppl slowly improve take the advice we give them and i notice it and reward it with packs.

A much easier system is like what One Piece has. Give all who participate in each match items from the packs. JUst split the amounts up based on final position of the groups. So everyone in the winning guild gets a hero pack if the attended all matches (total rewards after GNW).

I agree with this info.

I hope they will implement to track all those things in the game :)

Cant say thats much simplier. this idea yeah is good, better than mine. Nevertheless, i cant imagine where i can get so much info. I rule a group just for 4 weeks. I was senior on another server...but not leader. A bit hard :D.
I agree with Neconis a bit more. Still, last weeks i gave two of the most active memebrs packs. Noone diagreed with mine distributions. maybe just 2 mistakes we though. So 25/27 right decisions it seemed to be.....Nothing like this.
First received elite pack. He was in our group for 2-3 weeks: tried to max donations, he learned a lot..was talkative, nice guy, helped others... 2-3 ago he left our group and joined anopther. moreover made 3 his friends left.
Another one was amazing player. Like me: came from other servers. Joined group at first day. Was ANBU maxed donations, tought people to play... Nothing bad. Was in Top 10 in power from start. Received legendary... Now 4 days offline without words.
23/27 right decisions...
So now i understand that feelings of a leader may play a bad joke even with looking only on those improving/good players. Thats why i decided to make something new in my free time :D

the system should automatically give 1 pack to each member who attends 5 times. a pack with only (1 seal scroll) will be good enough, its not that much but it makes those who attend the GNW fell better. :P

The tracking of each activity to be accounted for requires the level of bureaucracy that stops this being a game for person doing it and becomes a 2nd job so no thanks. All thats really needed is just more packs or for game to award participants a seal scroll for each battle they win in war.

Not simpler? All you do is define the values for each method (type a number in), then select random distribution (click a *on). Everything is tracked and calculated server-side.

I suggested something similiar. http://forum.naruto.oasgames.com/en/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=8966&extra=page%3D1

Your systems is nice. But not only there is no way to collect such info, except manually with all working on it, Those who update game and make It better won't make upgrades that will deal with so much things. Too much work is needed. To track others gi, ti and other records also sounds a bit like stalking.
I can't imagine how to do it even on new servers where in groups there is no much people. In our group we have 21-34 gnw participants. In theory if that is possible it would be awsome. Just entering numbers and using random program.
The only things I see to be used is logical calculation of donations and gnw battles with addition to subjective points from leader that looks at overall participation (chat, gi, convoy and etc). Trying to make system based on these two parameters.
If you actually used your idea please tell me. It's too awesome(won't lie). I absolutely understand your ideas.

Yeah, agree. Jjust when they will make it? Or do they even think about this? We Have to deal with what we have now at least.

Hey guys :D

I made a suggestion on the forum about having a system that will check player performance in the group :)

http://forum.naruto.oasgames.com ... 100&page=1#pid55916

and I based the idea in this discussion :)

maybe if there is a lot of players that will support the idea :) They might implement it and it will greatly help us in handling gnw packs in the war :) This post was last edited by Vinze at 2016-11-23 07:25

I could literally have it done in an hour lol.

Maybe not a seal scroll.
Maybe a Summoning Scroll + 2-3 Seal frags + some coins or something. I dunno.
We already get a guaranteed one each week from chase missions. We also get fragments from Matsuri if not a whole seal scroll. Then there is Sage War. Then there is the mini-client Monday rewards that give you 5 seal frags. Then there is the Anko Test and Survival Trial which both can give out seal scrolls. Yeah, the 12th trial has given me some seal scrolls too.
Oh well, Just my opinion.
But I think the 1,000 group coins for participating in the war + 63 or whatever contributions already act like a small gift. Haha. It's just that nobody in the group shop is worth getting right now.

Just give it to those who deserve it. Those who prove them selves in that weeks war.
I mean, yeah its a * move but, why would would someone who didn't fight, or someone who did, but died quickly, why should they get a pack?

smh @ you..

increase GNW packs would help out greatly as well.