In previous Great Plates, a few times, there were Kisame's frag drops. You'd probably got him from there.

I have both Kisame and Madara. Both are great, but they work differently even though they're quite similar.

---

In some cases super armor is better than dodge. and sometimes unlimited dodge is good against heavy combo and hits.

There are a few chases those can't be dodged, which it can mess up Madara and your team's combo to damage reduction.

---

If I play Naruto, i'd take Kisame, along with earth main super armor. it's hard to focus and combo your team.